Skip to content
First AI Class

AI for Lawyers & Paralegals

Find the scope of AI guidance before relying on it

Headlines often compress several things into “new AI rules”: a proposal, a professional opinion, an adopted rule or a court's order. Those are different documents. Before applying one, identify who issued it, what it covers and whether it is in effect.

This page teaches source reading through fictional club notices. It is not current legal advice for your jurisdiction, a compliance checklist or a substitute for professional judgment.

Begin with the issuing authority

The State Bar of California's AI resource page links to guidance and materials from several jurisdictions. Use an index to locate an issuer's original document; inclusion in a collection does not make every item applicable everywhere. Check the original date, status, audience and any later amendment.

ABA Formal Opinion 512 is based on the Model Rules. It rejects generic engagement-letter boilerplate as sufficient informed consent when consent is required. Do not turn a general sentence or this page into permission for a particular use.

Practise reading three fictional notices

Supplied facts: All notices are invented. Cedar Club's adopted notice, effective 1 November, says members must book its upstairs room. Cedar Club's consultation draft proposes booking for all rooms from 1 December, but approval is not recorded. Birch Club's current notice says its own upstairs room needs no booking. Today in this exercise is 10 November. Nothing says the clubs share rules.

Practice prompt: State what these notices establish for Cedar Club today. Identify the draft proposal and explain whether Birch's notice answers Cedar's question. Do not infer an unmentioned approval or rule.

Deliberately flawed sample: “All Cedar rooms require booking now because the December draft is binding. Birch's notice also exempts Cedar's upstairs room.”

Preserve date, issuer and status

One possible correction: Cedar's adopted notice requires booking its upstairs room on 10 November. The all-room requirement is a proposal with no recorded approval, and its stated start date is later. Birch's notice addresses Birch, not Cedar. The supplied notices do not establish Cedar's requirements for other rooms.

Checks: Identify Cedar as the relevant issuer, distinguish the effective notice from the unapproved draft, keep the dates separate and reject the cross-club exemption. Do not conclude that other Cedar rooms are definitely free of booking requirements; the supplied set does not answer that question.

Limits: The clubs are fictional and the task is not statutory interpretation. Correct answers do not establish legal competence or certify an actual policy.

Keep a short source record

For an actual information search, note the issuing body, direct URL, document title, publication or effective date, location and task covered, and the part you still need clarified. Keep proposal status visible. A retrieved page can be authentic yet outdated or outside the relevant scope.

For professional work, consult the current applicable rules, relevant court requirements and qualified advice as needed. There is no fixed quarterly schedule here that guarantees you will catch an important change. The citation exercise offers another way to practise distinguishing what a source says from what someone claims it says.

For related practice, see the source-checking exercise and the confidentiality learning boundary.

Continue with general AI foundations

Open free foundation Module 1. An account is required, with no credit card. The course overview explains the foundation material and paid-access limits. This is general AI learning, not a legal practice qualification.

The starter quiz uses your goal, obstacle and available time to select a general rule-based plan. It does not approve a tool, identify every legal risk or measure professional readiness. You can also return to the AI for lawyers hub.

This revision received assistant source checking. That is not evidence of human legal review, regulatory approval or measured learning outcomes. Our methodology explains the review limits.

Frequently asked questions

Are ABA Model Rules automatically the rules in every jurisdiction?
No. Identify the applicable jurisdiction’s adopted requirements and relevant court orders. An ABA model or opinion is not a substitute for that check.
Is a general AI sentence in an engagement letter enough?
Do not assume it is. ABA Formal Opinion 512 says generic boilerplate is insufficient when informed consent is required. A real matter needs a fact-specific assessment.
Does this page keep track of every new rule?
No. It is a learning guide with dated sources, not a live legal update service. Reopen the applicable official source before relying on it.
Can a vendor certify that my workflow is compliant?
This page verifies no such certification. A vendor’s claim does not resolve the requirements applicable to your own matter, organization or court.
What should I do when the status of guidance is unclear?
Record the issuer, date, jurisdiction, scope and unresolved status. Get the authoritative text and qualified advice where needed rather than guessing that it is binding or irrelevant.

Related reading