Skip to content
First AI Class

AI for Lawyers & Paralegals

Check a citation and the claim it is meant to support

A polished reference can feel reassuring. The useful habit is to separate two questions: can you locate the source, and does it actually support the sentence? You can practise that distinction without inventing legal cases or working on a filing.

This page uses a fictional club handbook, not case law. It does not provide a complete legal-research method or a promised verification time.

Treat generated references as claims to check

NIST's generative AI risk profile describes confidently false generated content, including misleading citations. A fluent answer or an attached link is not evidence by itself. Asking the same tool to confirm its own answer is not an independent source check.

If a search returns nothing, record what you searched and what remains unresolved. Coverage, spelling and access can matter. Do not turn “I could not find it” into a factual conclusion that the source cannot exist, and do not rely on it as verified.

Practise with a fictional handbook

Supplied facts: This is the complete source set for the exercise. “Reading Club Handbook, version 2, section A: Members may borrow one display book for up to seven days.” “Version 2, section B: Large reference books stay in the room.” No section C is supplied. These are invented club rules, not law.

Practice prompt: Compare each claim in the sample with the supplied text. Mark it supported, contradicted or not established by these sources. Give a corrected summary without adding a rule.

Deliberately flawed sample: “Section A allows members to borrow three books for fourteen days. Section B allows reference books to leave the room. Section C sets a £5 late fee.”

Give evidence for each decision

One possible correction: The first claim is contradicted: section A allows one display book for up to seven days. The second is contradicted: section B keeps large reference books in the room. The £5 late fee is not established because no section C or fee rule was supplied. A supported summary is: “Members may borrow one display book for up to seven days; large reference books stay in the room.”

Checks: Identify both incorrect numbers, the reversed reference-book condition and the unsupported fee. Keep “up to” rather than changing it to a guaranteed seven-day loan. Do not say section C cannot exist outside this supplied set. Do not infer that there are no fees.

Limits: These answers are authored teaching examples. They do not verify an actual case, citation service or professional research capability.

Keep the scope of a check visible

A checking note can contain the claim, source title and version, exact supporting passage, your conclusion and the unresolved question. In this exercise, the missing fee rule belongs in the unresolved column. A different source version would require a new comparison; the version label is part of the evidence.

Real legal reliance adds questions this fictional task cannot answer, including jurisdiction, procedural context and later treatment. Use the appropriate authoritative sources and professional review process for that work. Do not treat this page or a chatbot response as authority. See finding the applicable guidance for a separate exercise in identifying scope.

For related practice, see the confidentiality learning boundary and the issuer and date exercise.

Continue with general AI foundations

Open free foundation Module 1. An account is required, with no credit card. The course overview explains the foundation material and paid-access limits. This is general AI learning, not a legal practice qualification.

The starter quiz uses your goal, obstacle and available time to select a general rule-based plan. It does not approve a tool, identify every legal risk or measure professional readiness. You can also return to the AI for lawyers hub.

This revision received assistant source checking. That is not evidence of human legal review, regulatory approval or measured learning outcomes. Our methodology explains the review limits.

Frequently asked questions

Does a failed database search prove a case is invented?
No. A search can fail because of a typo, coverage gap or another limitation. Keep an unresolved citation unverified rather than asserting either that it exists or that it is fabricated.
Is finding the case enough?
No. Existence, quotation accuracy, context, legal relevance and current authority are different questions. This introductory exercise covers only comparison with supplied fictional text.
Can a citation link guarantee accuracy?
No. A link gives you something to inspect; the linked text may not support the statement. Open the source and compare the specific claim rather than trusting the link label.
Does this exercise teach complete legal research?
No. A fictional handbook exercise does not assess jurisdiction, precedent or later treatment. Real legal research requires an appropriate professional process.
Will the quiz assess my readiness to file legal work?
No. It groups stated preferences into a general starter plan. It does not measure legal competence or authorize professional work.

Related reading